District Attorney's Office


Conasauga Judicial Circuit of Georgia

   Serving Murray & Whitfield Counties


January 22, 2019 (Dalton) – Superior Court Judge Cindy Morris today sentenced Cara Ann Williams, also known as Kaesarea Williams (37) to serve a total of 43 years without the possibility of parole on 16 total counts including aggravated identity fraud, forgery, financial transaction card theft and false statements. The sentence will run concurrent with a five-year no parole sentenced ordered by Judge Morris on a separate case involving the unlawful possession of a telephone in the Whitfield County Jail. The prior sentence was handed down on December 18, 2018 following a trial on that case.

Williams was convicted by a Whitfield County Jury on January 18th for the forgery, theft and fraud charges after a four-day trial. Senior Assistant District Attorney Mark Higgins presented the State’s case along with assistance from Detective Chris Tucker of the Dalton Police Department. Higgins tendered 140 exhibits and called 10 witnesses during the trial establishing that Williams had worked at two different local businesses using false identification documents and was found to be in possession of numerous other false documents and of stolen credit cards. The direct victim of the identity fraud, a former friend of the defendant and resident of North Carolina, testified about the financial and other problems caused by the Defendant’s actions over the past ten years. While Williams lied to detectives during the course of their investigation, she testified in her own defense at trial and on cross examination by Mr. Higgins, admitted to many aspects of the crimes with which she was charged. The jury deliberated approximately 12 minutes before returning a verdict of guilty on all counts. Williams was represented by local attorney Jerry Moncus.

Williams will be required to serve the entire sentence, day-for-day, without the possibility of parole due to her significant prior criminal history including eight (8) prior felony convictions for crimes including burglary, deposit account fraud, forgery, identity fraud, residential mortgage fraud, and theft. All of her prior felony convictions were from the Metro Atlanta area including Fulton, Cobb, Gwinnett, DeKalb and Clayton Counties. Court records show that Williams is originally from New York but lived in the Atlanta area for many years before recently moving to Chattanooga and then Dalton. Williams also has an active hold for similar charges out of Wilkinson County, east of Macon. In pronouncing sentence, Judge Morris told Williams she was a financial predator and was going to sentence her as she would any other predator. Morris proceeded to group Williams’ various crimes by type, sentencing her to serve five years on each forgery, all concurrent, followed by three years on each financial transaction card theft to run concurrent with each other but consecutive to the forgery counts, and that followed by five years on each of the false statements, concurrent with each other but consecutive to the other charges. Those sentences were then followed by 15 years on each of the two aggravated identity fraud counts which are required by law to run consecutively to each other and to any other crimes bringing the total sentence up to 43 years.

After sentencing, Higgins had the following to say about the case: “Over the years I have been a prosecutor, I have found that fraud related crimes are not something that get most prosecutors excited to come to work, myself included. They are time consuming cases, many times under-investigated, and often lacking in cooperation from the very financial institutions that should be the most cooperative. Generally, the few defendants deserving of and receiving prison time are paroled out before the ink is dry on their sentences. Fortunately, Detectives Chris Tucker and Aaron Simpson of the Dalton Police Department recognized this was a case deserving of more attention and put forth an outstanding effort in preparing this case. As a result, Ms. Williams, a habitual offender, will be significantly limited for the next several years in her ability to victimize others.”

Bert Poston
District Attorney
Conasauga Judicial Circuit

News Archive

Bert Poston,
District Attorney

 ©2012 Conasauga District Attorney's Office   conasauga-da.org